ZooKeeper: added comment [#CLICKHOUSE-2]

This commit is contained in:
Alexey Milovidov 2018-04-05 03:44:58 +03:00
parent b8df381a97
commit 0c519c763b

View File

@ -24,6 +24,52 @@
#include <functional>
/** ZooKeeper C++ library, a replacement for libzookeeper.
*
* Motivation.
*
* libzookeeper has many bugs:
* - segfaults: for example, if zookeeper connection was interrupted while reading result of multi response;
* - memory corruption: for example, as a result of double free inside libzookeeper;
* - no timeouts for synchronous operations: they may stuck forever under simple Jepsen-like tests;
* - logical errors: for example, chroot prefix is not removed from the results of multi responses.
* - data races;
*
* The code of libzookeeper is over complicated:
* - memory ownership is unclear and bugs are very difficult to track and fix.
* - extremely creepy code for implementation of "chroot" feature.
*
* As of 2018, there are no active maintainers of libzookeeper:
* - bugs in JIRA are fixed only occasionaly with ad-hoc patches by library users.
*
* libzookeeper is a classical example of bad code written in C.
*
* In Go, Python and Rust programming languages,
* there are separate libraries for ZooKeeper, not based on libzookeeper.
* Motivation is almost the same. Example:
* https://github.com/python-zk/kazoo/blob/master/docs/implementation.rst
*
* About "session restore" feature.
*
* libzookeeper has the feature of session restore. Client receives session id and session token from the server,
* and when connection is lost, it can quickly reconnect to any server with the same session id and token,
* to continue with existing session.
* libzookeeper performs this reconnection automatically.
*
* This feature is proven to be harmful.
* For example, it makes very difficult to correctly remove ephemeral nodes.
* This may lead to weird bugs in application code.
* For example, our developers have found that type of bugs in Curator Java library.
*
* On the other side, session restore feature has no advantages,
* because every application should be able to establish new session and reinitialize internal state,
* when the session is lost and cannot be restored.
*
* This library never restores the session. In case of any error, the session is considered as expired
* and you should create a new instance of ZooKeeperImpl object and reinitialize the application state.
*/
namespace CurrentMetrics
{
extern const Metric ZooKeeperSession;