thevar1able/ClickHouse
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/ClickHouse/ClickHouse.git synced 2024-11-10 01:25:21 +00:00
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Revert "Merge pull request #38200 from ClickHouse/keeper-linearizable-reads"

Browse Source 
This reverts commit 222b964070, reversing
changes made to da01982652.
This commit is contained in:
Alexander Tokmakov 2022-09-17 19:22:58 +02:00
parent 33216dedf9
commit 42dab6dc02
16 changed files with 130 additions and 584 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

2
contrib/NuRaft vendored

@ -1 +1 @@
Subproject commit e15858f8ad0ce8aba85cf74e3763874c76bf927c
Subproject commit 1be805e7cb2494aa8170015493474379b0362dfc

3
src/Coordination/CoordinationSettings.cpp
View File

@ -189,9 +189,6 @@ KeeperConfigurationAndSettings::loadFromConfig(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfigu
ret->coordination_settings->loadFromConfig("keeper_server.coordination_settings", config);
if (ret->coordination_settings->quorum_reads)
LOG_WARNING(&Poco::Logger::get("KeeperConfigurationAndSettings"), "Setting 'quorum_reads' is deprecated. Please use 'read_mode'");
return ret;
}

6
src/Coordination/CoordinationSettings.h
View File

@ -26,7 +26,6 @@ struct Settings;
M(Milliseconds, heart_beat_interval_ms, 500, "Heartbeat interval between quorum nodes", 0) \
M(Milliseconds, election_timeout_lower_bound_ms, 1000, "Lower bound of election timer (avoid too often leader elections)", 0) \
M(Milliseconds, election_timeout_upper_bound_ms, 2000, "Upper bound of election timer (avoid too often leader elections)", 0) \
M(Milliseconds, leadership_expiry, 0, "How often will leader node check if it still has majority. Set it lower or equal to election_timeout_lower_bound_ms to have linearizable reads.", 0) \
M(UInt64, reserved_log_items, 100000, "How many log items to store (don't remove during compaction)", 0) \
M(UInt64, snapshot_distance, 100000, "How many log items we have to collect to write new snapshot", 0) \
M(Bool, auto_forwarding, true, "Allow to forward write requests from followers to leader", 0) \
@ -39,12 +38,11 @@ struct Settings;
M(UInt64, stale_log_gap, 10000, "When node became stale and should receive snapshots from leader", 0) \
M(UInt64, fresh_log_gap, 200, "When node became fresh", 0) \
M(UInt64, max_requests_batch_size, 100, "Max size of batch in requests count before it will be sent to RAFT", 0) \
M(Bool, quorum_reads, false, "Deprecated - use read_mode. Execute read requests as writes through whole RAFT consesus with similar speed", 0) \
M(Bool, quorum_reads, false, "Execute read requests as writes through whole RAFT consesus with similar speed", 0) \
M(Bool, force_sync, true, "Call fsync on each change in RAFT changelog", 0) \
M(Bool, compress_logs, true, "Write compressed coordination logs in ZSTD format", 0) \
M(Bool, compress_snapshots_with_zstd_format, true, "Write compressed snapshots in ZSTD format (instead of custom LZ4)", 0) \
M(UInt64, configuration_change_tries_count, 20, "How many times we will try to apply configuration change (add/remove server) to the cluster", 0) \
M(String, read_mode, "nonlinear", "How should reads be processed. Valid values: 'nonlinear', 'fastlinear', 'quorum'. 'nonlinear' is the fastest option because there are no consistency requirements", 0)
M(UInt64, configuration_change_tries_count, 20, "How many times we will try to apply configuration change (add/remove server) to the cluster", 0)
DECLARE_SETTINGS_TRAITS(CoordinationSettingsTraits, LIST_OF_COORDINATION_SETTINGS)

493
src/Coordination/KeeperDispatcher.cpp
View File

@ -1,5 +1,4 @@
#include <Coordination/KeeperDispatcher.h>
#include <libnuraft/async.hxx>
#include <Common/setThreadName.h>
#include <Common/ZooKeeper/KeeperException.h>
#include <future>
@ -7,8 +6,6 @@
#include <Poco/Path.h>
#include <Common/hex.h>
#include <filesystem>
#include <iterator>
#include <limits>
#include <Common/checkStackSize.h>
#include <Common/CurrentMetrics.h>
@ -33,83 +30,22 @@ namespace ErrorCodes
KeeperDispatcher::KeeperDispatcher()
: responses_queue(std::numeric_limits<size_t>::max())
, read_requests_queue(std::numeric_limits<size_t>::max())
, finalize_requests_queue(std::numeric_limits<size_t>::max())
, configuration_and_settings(std::make_shared<KeeperConfigurationAndSettings>())
, log(&Poco::Logger::get("KeeperDispatcher"))
{
}
/// ZooKeepers has 2 requirements:
/// - writes need to be linearizable
/// - all requests from single session need to be processed in the order of their arrival
///
/// Because of that, we cannot process read and write requests from SAME session at the same time.
/// To be able to process read and write requests in parallel we need to make sure that only 1 type
/// of request is being processed from a single session.
/// Multiple types from different sessions can be processed at the same time.
///
/// We do some in-session housekeeping to make sure that the multithreaded request processing is correct.
/// When a request is received from a client, we check if there are requests being processed from that same
/// session, and if yes, of what type. If the types are the same, and there are no requests of different
/// type inbetetween, we can instanly add it to active request queue. Otherwise, we need to wait until
/// all requests of the other type are processed.
///
/// There are multiple threads used for processing the request, each of them communicating with a queue.
/// Assumption: only one type of request is being processed from a same session at any point in time (read or write).
///
/// requestThread -> requests currently being processed
/// readRequestThread -> thread for processing read requests
/// finalizeRequestThread -> thread for finalizing requests:
/// - in-session housekeeping, add requests to the active request queue if there are any
///
/// If reads are linearizable without quorum, a request can possibly wait for a certain log to be committed.
/// In that case we add it to the waiting queue for that log.
/// When that log is committed, the committing thread will send that read request to readRequestThread so it can be processed.
///
void KeeperDispatcher::requestThread()
{
setThreadName("KeeperReqT");
/// Result of requests batch from previous iteration
RaftResult prev_result = nullptr;
const auto previous_quorum_done = [&] { return !prev_result || prev_result->has_result() || prev_result->get_result_code() != nuraft::cmd_result_code::OK; };
RaftAppendResult prev_result = nullptr;
/// Requests from previous iteration. We store them to be able
/// to send errors to the client.
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions prev_batch;
const auto needs_quorum = [](const auto & coordination_settings, const auto & request)
{
return coordination_settings->quorum_reads || coordination_settings->read_mode.toString() == "quorum" || !request.request->isReadRequest();
};
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions quorum_requests;
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions read_requests;
auto process_quorum_requests = [&, this]() mutable
{
/// Forcefully process all previous pending requests
if (prev_result)
forceWaitAndProcessResult(prev_result);
prev_result = server->putRequestBatch(quorum_requests);
if (prev_result)
{
prev_result->when_ready([&, requests_for_sessions = std::move(quorum_requests)](nuraft::cmd_result<nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer>> & result, nuraft::ptr<std::exception> &) mutable
{
if (!result.get_accepted() || result.get_result_code() == nuraft::cmd_result_code::TIMEOUT)
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZOPERATIONTIMEOUT);
else if (result.get_result_code() != nuraft::cmd_result_code::OK)
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
});
}
quorum_requests.clear();
};
/// ZooKeeper requires that the requests inside a single session are processed in a strict order
/// (we cannot process later requests before all the previous once are processed)
/// By making sure that at this point we can either have just read requests or just write requests
/// from a single session, we can process them independently
while (!shutdown_called)
{
KeeperStorage::RequestForSession request;
@ -118,67 +54,94 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::requestThread()
uint64_t max_wait = coordination_settings->operation_timeout_ms.totalMilliseconds();
uint64_t max_batch_size = coordination_settings->max_requests_batch_size;
/// The code below do a very simple thing: batch all write (quorum) requests into vector until
/// previous write batch is not finished or max_batch size achieved. The main complexity goes from
/// the ability to process read requests without quorum (from local state). So when we are collecting
/// requests into a batch we must check that the new request is not read request. Otherwise we have to
/// process all already accumulated write requests, wait them synchronously and only after that process
/// read request. So reads are some kind of "separator" for writes.
try
{
if (active_requests_queue->tryPop(request, max_wait))
if (requests_queue->tryPop(request, max_wait))
{
CurrentMetrics::sub(CurrentMetrics::KeeperOutstandingRequets);
if (shutdown_called)
break;
if (needs_quorum(coordination_settings, request))
quorum_requests.emplace_back(request);
else
read_requests.emplace_back(request);
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions current_batch;
/// Waiting until previous append will be successful, or batch is big enough
/// has_result == false && get_result_code == OK means that our request still not processed.
/// Sometimes NuRaft set errorcode without setting result, so we check both here.
while (true)
bool has_read_request = false;
/// If new request is not read request or we must to process it through quorum.
/// Otherwise we will process it locally.
if (coordination_settings->quorum_reads || !request.request->isReadRequest())
{
if (quorum_requests.size() > max_batch_size)
break;
current_batch.emplace_back(request);
if (read_requests.size() > max_batch_size)
/// Waiting until previous append will be successful, or batch is big enough
/// has_result == false && get_result_code == OK means that our request still not processed.
/// Sometimes NuRaft set errorcode without setting result, so we check both here.
while (prev_result && (!prev_result->has_result() && prev_result->get_result_code() == nuraft::cmd_result_code::OK) && current_batch.size() <= max_batch_size)
{
processReadRequests(coordination_settings, read_requests);
/// Trying to get batch requests as fast as possible
if (requests_queue->tryPop(request, 1))
{
CurrentMetrics::sub(CurrentMetrics::KeeperOutstandingRequets);
/// Don't append read request into batch, we have to process them separately
if (!coordination_settings->quorum_reads && request.request->isReadRequest())
{
has_read_request = true;
break;
}
else
{
if (previous_quorum_done())
current_batch.emplace_back(request);
}
}
if (shutdown_called)
break;
}
/// Trying to get batch requests as fast as possible
if (active_requests_queue->tryPop(request, 1))
{
CurrentMetrics::sub(CurrentMetrics::KeeperOutstandingRequets);
if (needs_quorum(coordination_settings, request))
quorum_requests.emplace_back(request);
else
read_requests.emplace_back(request);
}
else
{
/// batch of read requests can send at most one request
/// so we don't care if the previous batch hasn't received response
if (!read_requests.empty())
processReadRequests(coordination_settings, read_requests);
/// if we still didn't process previous batch we can
/// increase are current batch even more
if (previous_quorum_done())
break;
}
if (shutdown_called)
break;
}
else
has_read_request = true;
if (shutdown_called)
break;
if (!quorum_requests.empty())
process_quorum_requests();
/// Forcefully process all previous pending requests
if (prev_result)
forceWaitAndProcessResult(prev_result, prev_batch);
/// Process collected write requests batch
if (!current_batch.empty())
{
auto result = server->putRequestBatch(current_batch);
if (result)
{
if (has_read_request) /// If we will execute read request next, than we have to process result now
forceWaitAndProcessResult(result, current_batch);
}
else
{
addErrorResponses(current_batch, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
current_batch.clear();
}
prev_batch = std::move(current_batch);
prev_result = result;
}
/// Read request always goes after write batch (last request)
if (has_read_request)
{
if (server->isLeaderAlive())
server->putLocalReadRequest(request);
else
addErrorResponses({request}, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
}
}
}
catch (...)
@ -188,72 +151,6 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::requestThread()
}
}
void KeeperDispatcher::processReadRequests(const CoordinationSettingsPtr & coordination_settings, KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & read_requests)
{
if (coordination_settings->read_mode.toString() == "fastlinear")
{
// we just want to know what's the current latest committed log on Leader node
auto leader_info_result = server->getLeaderInfo();
if (leader_info_result)
{
leader_info_result->when_ready([&, requests_for_sessions = std::move(read_requests)](nuraft::cmd_result<nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer>> & result, nuraft::ptr<std::exception> & exception) mutable
{
if (!result.get_accepted() || result.get_result_code() == nuraft::cmd_result_code::TIMEOUT)
{
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZOPERATIONTIMEOUT);
return;
}
if (result.get_result_code() != nuraft::cmd_result_code::OK)
{
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
return;
}
if (exception)
{
LOG_INFO(log, "Got exception while waiting for read results {}", exception->what());
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
return;
}
auto & leader_info_ctx = result.get();
if (!leader_info_ctx)
{
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
return;
}
KeeperServer::NodeInfo leader_info;
leader_info.term = leader_info_ctx->get_ulong();
leader_info.last_committed_index = leader_info_ctx->get_ulong();
std::lock_guard lock(leader_waiter_mutex);
auto node_info = server->getNodeInfo();
/// we're behind, we need to wait
if (node_info.term < leader_info.term || node_info.last_committed_index < leader_info.last_committed_index)
{
auto & leader_waiter = leader_waiters[leader_info];
leader_waiter.insert(leader_waiter.end(), requests_for_sessions.begin(), requests_for_sessions.end());
LOG_TRACE(log, "waiting for term {}, idx {}", leader_info.term, leader_info.last_committed_index);
}
/// process it in background thread
else if (!read_requests_queue.push(std::move(requests_for_sessions)))
throw Exception(ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR, "Cannot push read requests to queue");
});
}
}
else
{
assert(coordination_settings->read_mode.toString() == "nonlinear");
if (!read_requests_queue.push(std::move(read_requests)))
throw Exception(ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR, "Cannot push read requests to queue");
}
read_requests.clear();
}
void KeeperDispatcher::responseThread()
{
setThreadName("KeeperRspT");
@ -303,65 +200,6 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::snapshotThread()
}
}
/// Background thread for processing read requests
void KeeperDispatcher::readRequestThread()
{
setThreadName("KeeperReadT");
while (!shutdown_called)
{
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions requests;
if (!read_requests_queue.pop(requests))
break;
if (shutdown_called)
break;
try
{
for (const auto & request_info : requests)
{
if (server->isLeaderAlive())
server->putLocalReadRequest(request_info);
else
addErrorResponses({request_info}, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
}
if (!finalize_requests_queue.push(std::move(requests)))
throw Exception(ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR, "Cannot push read requests to queue");
}
catch (...)
{
tryLogCurrentException(__PRETTY_FUNCTION__);
}
}
}
/// We finalize requests every time we commit a single log with request
/// or process a batch of read requests.
/// Because it can get heavy, we do it in background thread.
void KeeperDispatcher::finalizeRequestsThread()
{
setThreadName("KeeperFinalT");
while (!shutdown_called)
{
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions requests;
if (!finalize_requests_queue.pop(requests))
break;
if (shutdown_called)
break;
try
{
finalizeRequests(requests);
}
catch (...)
{
tryLogCurrentException(__PRETTY_FUNCTION__);
}
}
}
void KeeperDispatcher::setResponse(int64_t session_id, const Coordination::ZooKeeperResponsePtr & response)
{
std::lock_guard lock(session_to_response_callback_mutex);
@ -417,30 +255,6 @@ bool KeeperDispatcher::putRequest(const Coordination::ZooKeeperRequestPtr & requ
request_info.time = duration_cast<milliseconds>(system_clock::now().time_since_epoch()).count();
request_info.session_id = session_id;
{
std::lock_guard lock{unprocessed_request_mutex};
auto unprocessed_requests_it = unprocessed_requests_for_session.find(session_id);
if (unprocessed_requests_it == unprocessed_requests_for_session.end())
{
auto & unprocessed_requests = unprocessed_requests_for_session[session_id];
unprocessed_requests.unprocessed_num = 1;
unprocessed_requests.is_read = request->isReadRequest();
}
else
{
auto & unprocessed_requests = unprocessed_requests_it->second;
/// queue is not empty, or the request types don't match, put it in the waiting queue
if (!unprocessed_requests.request_queue.empty() || unprocessed_requests.is_read != request->isReadRequest())
{
unprocessed_requests.request_queue.push_back(std::move(request_info));
return true;
}
++unprocessed_requests.unprocessed_num;
}
}
std::lock_guard lock(push_request_mutex);
if (shutdown_called)
@ -449,10 +263,10 @@ bool KeeperDispatcher::putRequest(const Coordination::ZooKeeperRequestPtr & requ
/// Put close requests without timeouts
if (request->getOpNum() == Coordination::OpNum::Close)
{
if (!active_requests_queue->push(std::move(request_info)))
if (!requests_queue->push(std::move(request_info)))
throw Exception("Cannot push request to queue", ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR);
}
else if (!active_requests_queue->tryPush(std::move(request_info), configuration_and_settings->coordination_settings->operation_timeout_ms.totalMilliseconds()))
else if (!requests_queue->tryPush(std::move(request_info), configuration_and_settings->coordination_settings->operation_timeout_ms.totalMilliseconds()))
{
throw Exception("Cannot push request to queue within operation timeout", ErrorCodes::TIMEOUT_EXCEEDED);
}
@ -465,23 +279,13 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::initialize(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & conf
LOG_DEBUG(log, "Initializing storage dispatcher");
configuration_and_settings = KeeperConfigurationAndSettings::loadFromConfig(config, standalone_keeper);
active_requests_queue = std::make_unique<RequestsQueue>(configuration_and_settings->coordination_settings->max_requests_batch_size);
requests_queue = std::make_unique<RequestsQueue>(configuration_and_settings->coordination_settings->max_requests_batch_size);
request_thread = ThreadFromGlobalPool([this] { requestThread(); });
responses_thread = ThreadFromGlobalPool([this] { responseThread(); });
snapshot_thread = ThreadFromGlobalPool([this] { snapshotThread(); });
read_request_thread = ThreadFromGlobalPool([this] { readRequestThread(); });
finalize_requests_thread = ThreadFromGlobalPool([this] { finalizeRequestsThread(); });
server = std::make_unique<KeeperServer>(
configuration_and_settings,
config,
responses_queue,
snapshots_queue,
[this](const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession & request_for_session, uint64_t log_term, uint64_t log_idx)
{ onRequestCommit(request_for_session, log_term, log_idx); },
[this](uint64_t term, uint64_t last_idx)
{ onApplySnapshot(term, last_idx); });
server = std::make_unique<KeeperServer>(configuration_and_settings, config, responses_queue, snapshots_queue);
try
{
@ -529,9 +333,9 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::shutdown()
if (session_cleaner_thread.joinable())
session_cleaner_thread.join();
if (active_requests_queue)
if (requests_queue)
{
active_requests_queue->finish();
requests_queue->finish();
if (request_thread.joinable())
request_thread.join();
@ -545,14 +349,6 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::shutdown()
if (snapshot_thread.joinable())
snapshot_thread.join();
read_requests_queue.finish();
if (read_request_thread.joinable())
read_request_thread.join();
finalize_requests_queue.finish();
if (finalize_requests_thread.joinable())
finalize_requests_thread.join();
update_configuration_queue.finish();
if (update_configuration_thread.joinable())
update_configuration_thread.join();
@ -561,7 +357,7 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::shutdown()
KeeperStorage::RequestForSession request_for_session;
/// Set session expired for all pending requests
while (active_requests_queue && active_requests_queue->tryPop(request_for_session))
while (requests_queue && requests_queue->tryPop(request_for_session))
{
CurrentMetrics::sub(CurrentMetrics::KeeperOutstandingRequets);
auto response = request_for_session.request->makeResponse();
@ -678,7 +474,7 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::sessionCleanerTask()
};
{
std::lock_guard lock(push_request_mutex);
if (!active_requests_queue->push(std::move(request_info)))
if (!requests_queue->push(std::move(request_info)))
LOG_INFO(log, "Cannot push close request to queue while cleaning outdated sessions");
CurrentMetrics::add(CurrentMetrics::KeeperOutstandingRequets);
}
@ -728,12 +524,19 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::addErrorResponses(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSession
}
}
void KeeperDispatcher::forceWaitAndProcessResult(RaftResult & result)
void KeeperDispatcher::forceWaitAndProcessResult(RaftAppendResult & result, KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests_for_sessions)
{
if (!result->has_result())
result->get();
/// If we get some errors, than send them to clients
if (!result->get_accepted() || result->get_result_code() == nuraft::cmd_result_code::TIMEOUT)
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZOPERATIONTIMEOUT);
else if (result->get_result_code() != nuraft::cmd_result_code::OK)
addErrorResponses(requests_for_sessions, Coordination::Error::ZCONNECTIONLOSS);
result = nullptr;
requests_for_sessions.clear();
}
int64_t KeeperDispatcher::getSessionID(int64_t session_timeout_ms)
@ -781,7 +584,7 @@ int64_t KeeperDispatcher::getSessionID(int64_t session_timeout_ms)
/// Push new session request to queue
{
std::lock_guard lock(push_request_mutex);
if (!active_requests_queue->tryPush(std::move(request_info), session_timeout_ms))
if (!requests_queue->tryPush(std::move(request_info), session_timeout_ms))
throw Exception("Cannot push session id request to queue within session timeout", ErrorCodes::TIMEOUT_EXCEEDED);
CurrentMetrics::add(CurrentMetrics::KeeperOutstandingRequets);
}
@ -854,122 +657,6 @@ void KeeperDispatcher::updateConfigurationThread()
}
}
// Used to update the state for a session based on the requests
// - update the number of current unprocessed requests for the session
// - if the number of unprocessed requests is 0, we can start adding next type of requests
// from unprocessed requests queue to the active queue
void KeeperDispatcher::finalizeRequests(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests_for_sessions)
{
std::unordered_map<int64_t, size_t> counts_for_session;
for (const auto & request_for_session : requests_for_sessions)
{
++counts_for_session[request_for_session.session_id];
}
std::lock_guard lock{unprocessed_request_mutex};
for (const auto [session_id, count] : counts_for_session)
{
auto unprocessed_requests_it = unprocessed_requests_for_session.find(session_id);
if (unprocessed_requests_it == unprocessed_requests_for_session.end())
continue;
auto & unprocessed_requests = unprocessed_requests_it->second;
unprocessed_requests.unprocessed_num -= count;
if (unprocessed_requests.unprocessed_num == 0)
{
if (!unprocessed_requests.request_queue.empty())
{
auto & unprocessed_requests_queue = unprocessed_requests.request_queue;
unprocessed_requests.is_read = !unprocessed_requests.is_read;
// start adding next type of requests
while (!unprocessed_requests_queue.empty() && unprocessed_requests_queue.front().request->isReadRequest() == unprocessed_requests.is_read)
{
auto & front_request = unprocessed_requests_queue.front();
/// Put close requests without timeouts
if (front_request.request->getOpNum() == Coordination::OpNum::Close)
{
if (!active_requests_queue->push(std::move(front_request)))
throw Exception("Cannot push request to queue", ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR);
}
else if (!active_requests_queue->tryPush(std::move(front_request), configuration_and_settings->coordination_settings->operation_timeout_ms.totalMilliseconds()))
{
throw Exception("Cannot push request to queue within operation timeout", ErrorCodes::TIMEOUT_EXCEEDED);
}
++unprocessed_requests.unprocessed_num;
unprocessed_requests_queue.pop_front();
}
}
else
{
unprocessed_requests_for_session.erase(unprocessed_requests_it);
}
}
}
}
// Finalize request
// Process read requests that were waiting for this commit
void KeeperDispatcher::onRequestCommit(const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession & request_for_session, uint64_t log_term, uint64_t log_idx)
{
if (!finalize_requests_queue.push({request_for_session}))
throw Exception(ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR, "Cannot push read requests to queue");
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions requests;
{
std::lock_guard lock(leader_waiter_mutex);
auto request_queue_it = leader_waiters.find(KeeperServer::NodeInfo{.term = log_term, .last_committed_index = log_idx});
if (request_queue_it != leader_waiters.end())
{
requests = std::move(request_queue_it->second);
leader_waiters.erase(request_queue_it);
}
}
if (requests.empty())
return;
if (!read_requests_queue.push(std::move(requests)))
throw Exception(ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR, "Cannot push read requests to queue");
}
/// Process all read request that are waiting for lower or currently last processed log index
void KeeperDispatcher::onApplySnapshot(uint64_t term, uint64_t last_idx)
{
KeeperServer::NodeInfo current_node_info{term, last_idx};
KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions requests;
{
std::lock_guard lock(leader_waiter_mutex);
for (auto leader_waiter_it = leader_waiters.begin(); leader_waiter_it != leader_waiters.end();)
{
auto waiting_node_info = leader_waiter_it->first;
if (waiting_node_info.term <= current_node_info.term
&& waiting_node_info.last_committed_index <= current_node_info.last_committed_index)
{
for (auto & request : leader_waiter_it->second)
{
requests.push_back(std::move(request));
}
leader_waiter_it = leader_waiters.erase(leader_waiter_it);
}
else
{
++leader_waiter_it;
}
}
}
if (requests.empty())
return;
if (!read_requests_queue.push(std::move(requests)))
throw Exception(ErrorCodes::SYSTEM_ERROR, "Cannot push read requests to queue");
}
bool KeeperDispatcher::isServerActive() const
{
return checkInit() && hasLeader() && !server->isRecovering();
@ -1034,7 +721,7 @@ Keeper4LWInfo KeeperDispatcher::getKeeper4LWInfo() const
Keeper4LWInfo result = server->getPartiallyFilled4LWInfo();
{
std::lock_guard lock(push_request_mutex);
result.outstanding_requests_count = active_requests_queue->size();
result.outstanding_requests_count = requests_queue->size();
}
{
std::lock_guard lock(session_to_response_callback_mutex);

49
src/Coordination/KeeperDispatcher.h
View File

@ -32,12 +32,9 @@ private:
using UpdateConfigurationQueue = ConcurrentBoundedQueue<ConfigUpdateAction>;
/// Size depends on coordination settings
/// Request currently being processed
std::unique_ptr<RequestsQueue> active_requests_queue;
std::unique_ptr<RequestsQueue> requests_queue;
ResponsesQueue responses_queue;
SnapshotsQueue snapshots_queue{1};
ConcurrentBoundedQueue<KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions> read_requests_queue;
ConcurrentBoundedQueue<KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions> finalize_requests_queue;
/// More than 1k updates is definitely misconfiguration.
UpdateConfigurationQueue update_configuration_queue{1000};
@ -67,8 +64,6 @@ private:
ThreadFromGlobalPool snapshot_thread;
/// Apply or wait for configuration changes
ThreadFromGlobalPool update_configuration_thread;
ThreadFromGlobalPool read_request_thread;
ThreadFromGlobalPool finalize_requests_thread;
/// RAFT wrapper.
std::unique_ptr<KeeperServer> server;
@ -82,34 +77,6 @@ private:
/// Counter for new session_id requests.
std::atomic<int64_t> internal_session_id_counter{0};
/// A read request needs to have at least the log it was the last committed log on the leader
/// at the time the request was being made.
/// If the node is stale, we need to wait to commit that log before doing local read requests to achieve
/// linearizability.
std::unordered_map<KeeperServer::NodeInfo, KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions> leader_waiters;
std::mutex leader_waiter_mutex;
/// We can be actively processing one type of requests (either read or write) from a single session.
/// If we receive a request of a type that is not currently being processed, we put it in the waiting queue.
/// Also, we want to process them in ariving order, so if we have a different type in the queue, we cannot process that request
/// but wait for all the previous requests to finish.
/// E.g. READ -> WRITE -> READ, the last READ will go to the waiting queue even though we are currently processing the first READ
/// because we have WRITE request before it that needs to be processed.
struct UnprocessedRequests
{
/// how many requests are currently in the active request queue
size_t unprocessed_num{0};
/// is_read currently being processed
bool is_read{false};
std::list<KeeperStorage::RequestForSession> request_queue;
};
// Called every time a batch of requests are processed.
void finalizeRequests(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests_for_sessions);
std::unordered_map<int64_t, UnprocessedRequests> unprocessed_requests_for_session;
std::mutex unprocessed_request_mutex;
/// Thread put requests to raft
void requestThread();
/// Thread put responses for subscribed sessions
@ -121,12 +88,6 @@ private:
/// Thread apply or wait configuration changes from leader
void updateConfigurationThread();
void readRequestThread();
void finalizeRequestsThread();
void processReadRequests(const CoordinationSettingsPtr & coordination_settings, KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & read_requests);
void setResponse(int64_t session_id, const Coordination::ZooKeeperResponsePtr & response);
/// Add error responses for requests to responses queue.
@ -135,7 +96,7 @@ private:
/// Forcefully wait for result and sets errors if something when wrong.
/// Clears both arguments
static void forceWaitAndProcessResult(RaftResult & result);
void forceWaitAndProcessResult(RaftAppendResult & result, KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests_for_sessions);
public:
/// Just allocate some objects, real initialization is done by `intialize method`
@ -155,12 +116,6 @@ public:
return server && server->checkInit();
}
/// Called when a single log with request is committed.
void onRequestCommit(const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession & request_for_session, uint64_t log_term, uint64_t log_idx);
/// Called when a snapshot is applied
void onApplySnapshot(uint64_t term, uint64_t last_idx);
/// Is server accepting requests, i.e. connected to the cluster
/// and achieved quorum
bool isServerActive() const;

47
src/Coordination/KeeperServer.cpp
View File

@ -105,9 +105,7 @@ KeeperServer::KeeperServer(
const KeeperConfigurationAndSettingsPtr & configuration_and_settings_,
const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & config,
ResponsesQueue & responses_queue_,
SnapshotsQueue & snapshots_queue_,
KeeperStateMachine::CommitCallback commit_callback,
KeeperStateMachine::ApplySnapshotCallback apply_snapshot_callback)
SnapshotsQueue & snapshots_queue_)
: server_id(configuration_and_settings_->server_id)
, coordination_settings(configuration_and_settings_->coordination_settings)
, log(&Poco::Logger::get("KeeperServer"))
@ -115,7 +113,7 @@ KeeperServer::KeeperServer(
, keeper_context{std::make_shared<KeeperContext>()}
, create_snapshot_on_exit(config.getBool("keeper_server.create_snapshot_on_exit", true))
{
if (coordination_settings->quorum_reads || coordination_settings->read_mode.toString() == "quorum")
if (coordination_settings->quorum_reads)
LOG_WARNING(log, "Quorum reads enabled, Keeper will work slower.");
keeper_context->digest_enabled = config.getBool("keeper_server.digest_enabled", false);
@ -127,9 +125,7 @@ KeeperServer::KeeperServer(
configuration_and_settings_->snapshot_storage_path,
coordination_settings,
keeper_context,
checkAndGetSuperdigest(configuration_and_settings_->super_digest),
std::move(commit_callback),
std::move(apply_snapshot_callback));
checkAndGetSuperdigest(configuration_and_settings_->super_digest));
state_manager = nuraft::cs_new<KeeperStateManager>(
server_id,
@ -180,13 +176,6 @@ struct KeeperServer::KeeperRaftServer : public nuraft::raft_server
reconfigure(new_config);
}
RaftResult getLeaderInfo()
{
nuraft::ptr<nuraft::req_msg> req
= nuraft::cs_new<nuraft::req_msg>(0ull, nuraft::msg_type::leader_status_request, 0, 0, 0ull, 0ull, 0ull);
return send_msg_to_leader(req);
}
void commit_in_bg() override
{
// For NuRaft, if any commit fails (uncaught exception) the whole server aborts as a safety
@ -280,20 +269,6 @@ void KeeperServer::launchRaftServer(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & co
coordination_settings->election_timeout_lower_bound_ms.totalMilliseconds(), "election_timeout_lower_bound_ms", log);
params.election_timeout_upper_bound_ = getValueOrMaxInt32AndLogWarning(
coordination_settings->election_timeout_upper_bound_ms.totalMilliseconds(), "election_timeout_upper_bound_ms", log);
params.leadership_expiry_ = getValueOrMaxInt32AndLogWarning(coordination_settings->leadership_expiry.totalMilliseconds(), "leadership_expiry", log);
if (coordination_settings->read_mode.toString() == "fastlinear")
{
if (params.leadership_expiry_ == 0)
params.leadership_expiry_ = params.election_timeout_lower_bound_;
else if (params.leadership_expiry_ > params.election_timeout_lower_bound_)
{
LOG_WARNING(log, "To use fast linearizable reads, leadership_expiry should be set to a value that is less or equal to the election_timeout_upper_bound_ms. "
"Based on current settings, there are no guarantees for linearizability of reads.");
}
}
params.reserved_log_items_ = getValueOrMaxInt32AndLogWarning(coordination_settings->reserved_log_items, "reserved_log_items", log);
params.snapshot_distance_ = getValueOrMaxInt32AndLogWarning(coordination_settings->snapshot_distance, "snapshot_distance", log);
@ -512,7 +487,7 @@ void KeeperServer::putLocalReadRequest(const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession &
state_machine->processReadRequest(request_for_session);
}
RaftResult KeeperServer::putRequestBatch(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests_for_sessions)
RaftAppendResult KeeperServer::putRequestBatch(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests_for_sessions)
{
std::vector<nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer>> entries;
for (const auto & request_for_session : requests_for_sessions)
@ -738,20 +713,6 @@ std::vector<int64_t> KeeperServer::getDeadSessions()
return state_machine->getDeadSessions();
}
RaftResult KeeperServer::getLeaderInfo()
{
std::lock_guard lock{server_write_mutex};
if (is_recovering)
return nullptr;
return raft_instance->getLeaderInfo();
}
KeeperServer::NodeInfo KeeperServer::getNodeInfo()
{
return { .term = raft_instance->get_term(), .last_committed_index = state_machine->last_commit_index() };
}
ConfigUpdateActions KeeperServer::getConfigurationDiff(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & config)
{
auto diff = state_manager->getConfigurationDiff(config);

34
src/Coordination/KeeperServer.h
View File

@ -14,7 +14,7 @@
namespace DB
{
using RaftResult = nuraft::ptr<nuraft::cmd_result<nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer>>>;
using RaftAppendResult = nuraft::ptr<nuraft::cmd_result<nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer>>>;
class KeeperServer
{
@ -71,9 +71,7 @@ public:
const KeeperConfigurationAndSettingsPtr & settings_,
const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & config_,
ResponsesQueue & responses_queue_,
SnapshotsQueue & snapshots_queue_,
KeeperStateMachine::CommitCallback commit_callback,
KeeperStateMachine::ApplySnapshotCallback apply_snapshot_callback);
SnapshotsQueue & snapshots_queue_);
/// Load state machine from the latest snapshot and load log storage. Start NuRaft with required settings.
void startup(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & config, bool enable_ipv6 = true);
@ -86,7 +84,7 @@ public:
/// Put batch of requests into Raft and get result of put. Responses will be set separately into
/// responses_queue.
RaftResult putRequestBatch(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests);
RaftAppendResult putRequestBatch(const KeeperStorage::RequestsForSessions & requests);
/// Return set of the non-active sessions
std::vector<int64_t> getDeadSessions();
@ -121,17 +119,6 @@ public:
int getServerID() const { return server_id; }
struct NodeInfo
{
uint64_t term;
uint64_t last_committed_index;
bool operator==(const NodeInfo &) const = default;
};
RaftResult getLeaderInfo();
NodeInfo getNodeInfo();
/// Get configuration diff between current configuration in RAFT and in XML file
ConfigUpdateActions getConfigurationDiff(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfiguration & config);
@ -139,23 +126,10 @@ public:
/// Synchronously check for update results with retries.
void applyConfigurationUpdate(const ConfigUpdateAction & task);
/// Wait configuration update for action. Used by followers.
/// Return true if update was successfully received.
bool waitConfigurationUpdate(const ConfigUpdateAction & task);
};
}
namespace std
{
template <>
struct hash<DB::KeeperServer::NodeInfo>
{
size_t operator()(const DB::KeeperServer::NodeInfo & info) const
{
SipHash hash_state;
hash_state.update(info.term);
hash_state.update(info.last_committed_index);
return hash_state.get64();
}
};
}

20
src/Coordination/KeeperStateMachine.cpp
View File

@ -44,9 +44,7 @@ KeeperStateMachine::KeeperStateMachine(
const std::string & snapshots_path_,
const CoordinationSettingsPtr & coordination_settings_,
const KeeperContextPtr & keeper_context_,
const std::string & superdigest_,
CommitCallback commit_callback_,
ApplySnapshotCallback apply_snapshot_callback_)
const std::string & superdigest_)
: coordination_settings(coordination_settings_)
, snapshot_manager(
snapshots_path_,
@ -60,8 +58,6 @@ KeeperStateMachine::KeeperStateMachine(
, last_committed_idx(0)
, log(&Poco::Logger::get("KeeperStateMachine"))
, superdigest(superdigest_)
, commit_callback(std::move(commit_callback_))
, apply_snapshot_callback(std::move(apply_snapshot_callback_))
, keeper_context(keeper_context_)
{
}
@ -227,11 +223,11 @@ bool KeeperStateMachine::preprocess(const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession & req
return true;
}
nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer> KeeperStateMachine::commit_ext(const ext_op_params & params)
nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer> KeeperStateMachine::commit(const uint64_t log_idx, nuraft::buffer & data)
{
auto request_for_session = parseRequest(*params.data);
auto request_for_session = parseRequest(data);
if (!request_for_session.zxid)
request_for_session.zxid = params.log_idx;
request_for_session.zxid = log_idx;
/// Special processing of session_id request
if (request_for_session.request->getOpNum() == Coordination::OpNum::SessionID)
@ -276,9 +272,8 @@ nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer> KeeperStateMachine::commit_ext(const ext_op_params &
assertDigest(*request_for_session.digest, storage->getNodesDigest(true), *request_for_session.request, true);
}
last_committed_idx = params.log_idx;
commit_callback(request_for_session, params.log_term, params.log_idx);
ProfileEvents::increment(ProfileEvents::KeeperCommits);
last_committed_idx = log_idx;
return nullptr;
}
@ -311,7 +306,6 @@ bool KeeperStateMachine::apply_snapshot(nuraft::snapshot & s)
ProfileEvents::increment(ProfileEvents::KeeperSnapshotApplys);
last_committed_idx = s.get_last_log_idx();
apply_snapshot_callback(s.get_last_log_term(), s.get_last_log_idx());
return true;
}
@ -326,10 +320,6 @@ void KeeperStateMachine::commit_config(const uint64_t /* log_idx */, nuraft::ptr
void KeeperStateMachine::rollback(uint64_t log_idx, nuraft::buffer & data)
{
auto request_for_session = parseRequest(data);
if (request_for_session.request->getOpNum() == Coordination::OpNum::SessionID)
return;
// If we received a log from an older node, use the log_idx as the zxid
// log_idx will always be larger or equal to the zxid so we can safely do this
// (log_idx is increased for all logs, while zxid is only increased for requests)

14
src/Coordination/KeeperStateMachine.h
View File

@ -20,18 +20,13 @@ using SnapshotsQueue = ConcurrentBoundedQueue<CreateSnapshotTask>;
class KeeperStateMachine : public nuraft::state_machine
{
public:
using CommitCallback = std::function<void(const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession &, uint64_t, uint64_t)>;
using ApplySnapshotCallback = std::function<void(uint64_t, uint64_t)>;
KeeperStateMachine(
ResponsesQueue & responses_queue_,
SnapshotsQueue & snapshots_queue_,
const std::string & snapshots_path_,
const CoordinationSettingsPtr & coordination_settings_,
const KeeperContextPtr & keeper_context_,
const std::string & superdigest_ = "",
CommitCallback commit_callback_ = [](const KeeperStorage::RequestForSession &, uint64_t, uint64_t){},
ApplySnapshotCallback apply_snapshot_callback_ = [](uint64_t, uint64_t){});
const std::string & superdigest_ = "");
/// Read state from the latest snapshot
void init();
@ -42,7 +37,7 @@ public:
nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer> pre_commit(uint64_t log_idx, nuraft::buffer & data) override;
nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer> commit_ext(const ext_op_params & params) override; /// NOLINT
nuraft::ptr<nuraft::buffer> commit(const uint64_t log_idx, nuraft::buffer & data) override; /// NOLINT
/// Save new cluster config to our snapshot (copy of the config stored in StateManager)
void commit_config(const uint64_t log_idx, nuraft::ptr<nuraft::cluster_config> & new_conf) override; /// NOLINT
@ -150,11 +145,6 @@ private:
/// Special part of ACL system -- superdigest specified in server config.
const std::string superdigest;
/// call when a request is committed
const CommitCallback commit_callback;
/// call when snapshot is applied
const ApplySnapshotCallback apply_snapshot_callback;
KeeperContextPtr keeper_context;
};

22
src/Coordination/tests/gtest_coordination.cpp
View File

@ -1330,9 +1330,8 @@ void testLogAndStateMachine(Coordination::CoordinationSettingsPtr settings, uint
changelog.append(entry);
changelog.end_of_append_batch(0, 0);
auto entry_buf = changelog.entry_at(i)->get_buf_ptr();
state_machine->pre_commit(i, *entry_buf);
state_machine->commit_ext(nuraft::state_machine::ext_op_params{i, entry_buf});
state_machine->pre_commit(i, changelog.entry_at(i)->get_buf());
state_machine->commit(i, changelog.entry_at(i)->get_buf());
bool snapshot_created = false;
if (i % settings->snapshot_distance == 0)
{
@ -1376,9 +1375,8 @@ void testLogAndStateMachine(Coordination::CoordinationSettingsPtr settings, uint
for (size_t i = restore_machine->last_commit_index() + 1; i < restore_changelog.next_slot(); ++i)
{
auto entry = changelog.entry_at(i)->get_buf_ptr();
restore_machine->pre_commit(i, *entry);
restore_machine->commit_ext(nuraft::state_machine::ext_op_params{i, entry});
restore_machine->pre_commit(i, changelog.entry_at(i)->get_buf());
restore_machine->commit(i, changelog.entry_at(i)->get_buf());
}
auto & source_storage = state_machine->getStorage();
@ -1479,18 +1477,18 @@ TEST_P(CoordinationTest, TestEphemeralNodeRemove)
std::shared_ptr<ZooKeeperCreateRequest> request_c = std::make_shared<ZooKeeperCreateRequest>();
request_c->path = "/hello";
request_c->is_ephemeral = true;
auto entry_c = getLogEntryFromZKRequest(0, 1, state_machine->getNextZxid(), request_c)->get_buf_ptr();
state_machine->pre_commit(1, *entry_c);
state_machine->commit_ext(nuraft::state_machine::ext_op_params{1, entry_c});
auto entry_c = getLogEntryFromZKRequest(0, 1, state_machine->getNextZxid(), request_c);
state_machine->pre_commit(1, entry_c->get_buf());
state_machine->commit(1, entry_c->get_buf());
const auto & storage = state_machine->getStorage();
EXPECT_EQ(storage.ephemerals.size(), 1);
std::shared_ptr<ZooKeeperRemoveRequest> request_d = std::make_shared<ZooKeeperRemoveRequest>();
request_d->path = "/hello";
/// Delete from other session
auto entry_d = getLogEntryFromZKRequest(0, 2, state_machine->getNextZxid(), request_d)->get_buf_ptr();
state_machine->pre_commit(2, *entry_d);
state_machine->commit_ext(nuraft::state_machine::ext_op_params{2, entry_d});
auto entry_d = getLogEntryFromZKRequest(0, 2, state_machine->getNextZxid(), request_d);
state_machine->pre_commit(2, entry_d->get_buf());
state_machine->commit(2, entry_d->get_buf());
EXPECT_EQ(storage.ephemerals.size(), 0);
}

3
tests/jepsen.clickhouse-keeper/resources/keeper_config.xml
View File

@ -21,8 +21,7 @@
<heart_beat_interval_ms>1000</heart_beat_interval_ms>
<election_timeout_lower_bound_ms>2000</election_timeout_lower_bound_ms>
<election_timeout_upper_bound_ms>4000</election_timeout_upper_bound_ms>
<quorum_reads>0</quorum_reads>
<read_mode>fastlinear</read_mode>
<quorum_reads>{quorum_reads}</quorum_reads>
<snapshot_distance>{snapshot_distance}</snapshot_distance>
<stale_log_gap>{stale_log_gap}</stale_log_gap>
<reserved_log_items>{reserved_log_items}</reserved_log_items>

13
tests/jepsen.clickhouse-keeper/src/jepsen/clickhouse_keeper/counter.clj
View File

@ -27,12 +27,7 @@
(invoke! [this test op]
(case (:f op)
:read (try
(assoc op
:type :ok
:value (count (zk-list conn root-path)))
(catch Exception _ (assoc op :type :info, :error :connect-error)))
:final-read (exec-with-retries 30 (fn []
:read (exec-with-retries 30 (fn []
(assoc op
:type :ok
:value (count (zk-list conn root-path)))))
@ -54,5 +49,7 @@
:checker (checker/compose
{:counter (checker/counter)
:perf (checker/perf)})
:generator (gen/mix [r add])
:final-generator (gen/once {:type :invoke, :f :final-read, :value nil})})
:generator (->> (range)
(map (fn [x]
(->> (gen/mix [r add])))))
:final-generator (gen/once {:type :invoke, :f :read, :value nil})})

1
tests/jepsen.clickhouse-keeper/src/jepsen/clickhouse_keeper/db.clj
View File

@ -98,6 +98,7 @@
#"\{srv2\}" (get nodes 1)
#"\{srv3\}" (get nodes 2)
#"\{id\}" (str (inc (.indexOf nodes node)))
#"\{quorum_reads\}" (str (boolean (:quorum test)))
#"\{snapshot_distance\}" (str (:snapshot-distance test))
#"\{stale_log_gap\}" (str (:stale-log-gap test))
#"\{reserved_log_items\}" (str (:reserved-log-items test))}]

2
tests/jepsen.clickhouse-keeper/src/jepsen/clickhouse_keeper/main.clj
View File

@ -103,7 +103,7 @@
current-nemesis (get custom-nemesis/custom-nemesises (:nemesis opts))]
(merge tests/noop-test
opts
{:name (str "clickhouse-keeper-" (name (:workload opts)) "-" (name (:nemesis opts)))
{:name (str "clickhouse-keeper-quorum=" quorum "-" (name (:workload opts)) "-" (name (:nemesis opts)))
:os ubuntu/os
:db (get-db opts)
:pure-generators true

3
tests/jepsen.clickhouse-keeper/src/jepsen/clickhouse_keeper/register.clj
View File

@ -20,8 +20,7 @@
(assoc this :conn (zk-connect node 9181 30000)))
(setup! [this test]
(exec-with-retries 30 (fn []
(zk-create-range conn 300))))
(zk-create-range conn 300)) ; 300 nodes to be sure
(invoke! [_ test op]
(let [[k v] (:value op)

2
tests/jepsen.clickhouse-keeper/src/jepsen/clickhouse_keeper/utils.clj
View File

@ -45,7 +45,7 @@
(defn zk-connect
[host port timeout]
(zk/connect (str host ":" port) :timeout-msec timeout))
(exec-with-retries 30 (fn [] (zk/connect (str host ":" port) :timeout-msec timeout))))
(defn zk-create-range
[conn n]