Merge c5c208e639 into 7eee149487

FIx 02374_analyzer_join_using

src/Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeper.cpp

@@ -341,7 +341,10 @@ Coordination::Error ZooKeeper::tryGetChildren(
     const EventPtr & watch,
     Coordination::ListRequestType list_request_type)
 {
-    return tryGetChildrenWatch(path, res, stat,
+    return tryGetChildrenWatch(
+        path,
+        res,
+        stat,
         watch ? std::make_shared<Coordination::WatchCallback>(callbackForEvent(watch)) : Coordination::WatchCallbackPtr{},
         list_request_type);
 }
@@ -975,11 +978,14 @@ void ZooKeeper::removeRecursive(const std::string & path, uint32_t remove_nodes_
 
 Coordination::Error ZooKeeper::tryRemoveRecursive(const std::string & path, uint32_t remove_nodes_limit)
 {
-    if (!isFeatureEnabled(DB::KeeperFeatureFlag::REMOVE_RECURSIVE))
+    const auto fallback_method = [&]
     {
         tryRemoveChildrenRecursive(path);
         return tryRemove(path);
-    }
+    };
+
+    if (!isFeatureEnabled(DB::KeeperFeatureFlag::REMOVE_RECURSIVE))
+        return fallback_method();
 
     auto promise = std::make_shared<std::promise<Coordination::RemoveRecursiveResponse>>();
     auto future = promise->get_future();
@@ -998,6 +1004,10 @@ Coordination::Error ZooKeeper::tryRemoveRecursive(const std::string & path, uint
     }
 
     auto response = future.get();
+
+    if (response.error == Coordination::Error::ZNOTEMPTY) /// limit was too low, try without RemoveRecursive request
+        return fallback_method();
+
     return response.error;
 }
 

src/Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeper.h

@@ -486,13 +486,13 @@ public:
     /// Remove the node with the subtree.
     /// If Keeper supports RemoveRecursive operation then it will be performed atomically.
     /// Otherwise if someone concurrently adds or removes a node in the subtree, the result is undefined.
-    void removeRecursive(const std::string & path, uint32_t remove_nodes_limit = 100);
+    void removeRecursive(const std::string & path, uint32_t remove_nodes_limit = 1000);
 
     /// Same as removeRecursive but in case if Keeper does not supports RemoveRecursive and
     /// if someone concurrently removes a node in the subtree, this will not cause errors.
     /// For instance, you can call this method twice concurrently for the same node and the end
     /// result would be the same as for the single call.
-    Coordination::Error tryRemoveRecursive(const std::string & path, uint32_t remove_nodes_limit = 100);
+    Coordination::Error tryRemoveRecursive(const std::string & path, uint32_t remove_nodes_limit = 1000);
 
     /// Similar to removeRecursive(...) and tryRemoveRecursive(...), but does not remove path itself.
     /// Node defined as RemoveException will not be deleted.

src/Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperCommon.cpp

@@ -767,6 +767,11 @@ size_t ZooKeeperMultiRequest::sizeImpl() const
 }
 
 void ZooKeeperMultiRequest::readImpl(ReadBuffer & in)
+{
+    readImpl(in, /*request_validator=*/{});
+}
+
+void ZooKeeperMultiRequest::readImpl(ReadBuffer & in, RequestValidator request_validator)
 {
     while (true)
     {
@@ -788,6 +793,8 @@ void ZooKeeperMultiRequest::readImpl(ReadBuffer & in)
 
         ZooKeeperRequestPtr request = ZooKeeperRequestFactory::instance().get(op_num);
         request->readImpl(in);
+        if (request_validator)
+            request_validator(*request);
         requests.push_back(request);
 
         if (in.eof())

src/Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperCommon.h

@@ -570,6 +570,9 @@ struct ZooKeeperMultiRequest final : MultiRequest<ZooKeeperRequestPtr>, ZooKeepe
     void writeImpl(WriteBuffer & out) const override;
     size_t sizeImpl() const override;
     void readImpl(ReadBuffer & in) override;
+
+    using RequestValidator = std::function<void(const ZooKeeperRequest &)>;
+    void readImpl(ReadBuffer & in, RequestValidator request_validator);
     std::string toStringImpl(bool short_format) const override;
 
     ZooKeeperResponsePtr makeResponse() const override;

src/Coordination/KeeperContext.cpp

@@ -514,7 +514,13 @@ void KeeperContext::initializeFeatureFlags(const Poco::Util::AbstractConfigurati
                 feature_flags.disableFeatureFlag(feature_flag.value());
         }
 
+        if (feature_flags.isEnabled(KeeperFeatureFlag::MULTI_READ))
+            feature_flags.enableFeatureFlag(KeeperFeatureFlag::FILTERED_LIST);
+        else
+            system_nodes_with_data[keeper_api_version_path] = toString(static_cast<uint8_t>(KeeperApiVersion::ZOOKEEPER_COMPATIBLE));
+
         system_nodes_with_data[keeper_api_feature_flags_path] = feature_flags.getFeatureFlags();
+
     }
 
     feature_flags.logFlags(getLogger("KeeperContext"));
@@ -569,6 +575,25 @@ const CoordinationSettings & KeeperContext::getCoordinationSettings() const
     return *coordination_settings;
 }
 
+bool KeeperContext::isOperationSupported(Coordination::OpNum operation) const
+{
+    switch (operation)
+    {
+        case Coordination::OpNum::FilteredList:
+            return feature_flags.isEnabled(KeeperFeatureFlag::FILTERED_LIST);
+        case Coordination::OpNum::MultiRead:
+            return feature_flags.isEnabled(KeeperFeatureFlag::MULTI_READ);
+        case Coordination::OpNum::CreateIfNotExists:
+            return feature_flags.isEnabled(KeeperFeatureFlag::CREATE_IF_NOT_EXISTS);
+        case Coordination::OpNum::CheckNotExists:
+            return feature_flags.isEnabled(KeeperFeatureFlag::CHECK_NOT_EXISTS);
+        case Coordination::OpNum::RemoveRecursive:
+            return feature_flags.isEnabled(KeeperFeatureFlag::REMOVE_RECURSIVE);
+        default:
+            return true;
+    }
+}
+
 uint64_t KeeperContext::lastCommittedIndex() const
 {
     return last_committed_log_idx.load(std::memory_order_relaxed);

src/Coordination/KeeperContext.h

@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 #pragma once
 #include <Coordination/KeeperFeatureFlags.h>
 #include <Poco/Util/AbstractConfiguration.h>
+#include <Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperConstants.h>
 #include <atomic>
 #include <condition_variable>
 #include <cstdint>
@@ -103,6 +104,7 @@ public:
         return precommit_sleep_probability_for_testing;
     }
 
+    bool isOperationSupported(Coordination::OpNum operation) const;
 private:
     /// local disk defined using path or disk name
     using Storage = std::variant<DiskPtr, std::string>;

src/Server/KeeperTCPHandler.cpp

@@ -1,5 +1,4 @@
 #include <Server/KeeperTCPHandler.h>
-#include "Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperConstants.h"
 
 #if USE_NURAFT
 
@@ -19,6 +18,8 @@
 #    include <Common/NetException.h>
 #    include <Common/PipeFDs.h>
 #    include <Common/Stopwatch.h>
+#    include <Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperCommon.h>
+#    include <Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperConstants.h>
 #    include <Common/ZooKeeper/ZooKeeperIO.h>
 #    include <Common/logger_useful.h>
 #    include <Common/setThreadName.h>
@@ -63,6 +64,7 @@ namespace ErrorCodes
     extern const int LOGICAL_ERROR;
     extern const int UNEXPECTED_PACKET_FROM_CLIENT;
     extern const int TIMEOUT_EXCEEDED;
+    extern const int BAD_ARGUMENTS;
 }
 
 struct PollResult
@@ -637,7 +639,23 @@ std::pair<Coordination::OpNum, Coordination::XID> KeeperTCPHandler::receiveReque
 
     Coordination::ZooKeeperRequestPtr request = Coordination::ZooKeeperRequestFactory::instance().get(opnum);
     request->xid = xid;
-    request->readImpl(read_buffer);
+
+    auto request_validator = [&](const Coordination::ZooKeeperRequest & current_request)
+    {
+        if (!keeper_dispatcher->getKeeperContext()->isOperationSupported(current_request.getOpNum()))
+            throw Exception(ErrorCodes::BAD_ARGUMENTS, "Unsupported operation: {}", current_request.getOpNum());
+    };
+
+    if (auto * multi_request = dynamic_cast<Coordination::ZooKeeperMultiRequest *>(request.get()))
+    {
+        multi_request->readImpl(read_buffer, request_validator);
+    }
+    else
+    {
+        request->readImpl(read_buffer);
+        request_validator(*request);
+    }
+
 
     if (!keeper_dispatcher->putRequest(request, session_id, use_xid_64))
         throw Exception(ErrorCodes::TIMEOUT_EXCEEDED, "Session {} already disconnected", session_id);

src/Storages/MergeTree/MergeTreeReadPoolParallelReplicasInOrder.cpp

@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
 #include <Storages/MergeTree/MergeTreeReadPoolParallelReplicasInOrder.h>
+#include <Storages/MergeTree/MergeTreeSettings.h>
 
 namespace ProfileEvents
 {
@@ -10,8 +11,13 @@ namespace DB
 
 namespace ErrorCodes
 {
-    extern const int LOGICAL_ERROR;
-    extern const int BAD_ARGUMENTS;
+extern const int LOGICAL_ERROR;
+extern const int BAD_ARGUMENTS;
+}
+
+namespace MergeTreeSetting
+{
+extern const MergeTreeSettingsUInt64 index_granularity;
 }
 
 MergeTreeReadPoolParallelReplicasInOrder::MergeTreeReadPoolParallelReplicasInOrder(
@@ -65,21 +71,77 @@ MergeTreeReadTaskPtr MergeTreeReadPoolParallelReplicasInOrder::getTask(size_t ta
     std::lock_guard lock(mutex);
 
     if (task_idx >= per_part_infos.size())
-        throw Exception(ErrorCodes::LOGICAL_ERROR,
-            "Requested task with idx {}, but there are only {} parts",
-            task_idx, per_part_infos.size());
+        throw Exception(
+            ErrorCodes::LOGICAL_ERROR, "Requested task with idx {}, but there are only {} parts", task_idx, per_part_infos.size());
 
     const auto & part_info = per_part_infos[task_idx]->data_part->info;
-    auto get_from_buffer = [&]() -> std::optional<MarkRanges>
+    const auto & data_settings = per_part_infos[task_idx]->data_part->storage.getSettings();
+    auto get_from_buffer = [&,
+                            rows_granularity = (*data_settings)[MergeTreeSetting::index_granularity],
+                            my_max_block_size = this->block_size_params.max_block_size_rows]() -> std::optional<MarkRanges>
     {
+        const size_t max_marks_in_range = (my_max_block_size + rows_granularity - 1) / rows_granularity;
         for (auto & desc : buffered_tasks)
         {
             if (desc.info == part_info && !desc.ranges.empty())
             {
-                auto result = std::move(desc.ranges);
-                desc.ranges = MarkRanges{};
-                ProfileEvents::increment(ProfileEvents::ParallelReplicasReadMarks, desc.ranges.getNumberOfMarks());
-                return result;
+                if (mode == CoordinationMode::WithOrder)
+                {
+                    /// if already splited, just return desc.ranges
+                    if (split)
+                    {
+                        auto result = std::move(desc.ranges);
+                        desc.ranges = MarkRanges{};
+                        ProfileEvents::increment(ProfileEvents::ParallelReplicasReadMarks, result.getNumberOfMarks());
+                        return result;
+                    }
+
+                    /// else split range but still return all MarkRanges
+                    MarkRanges result;
+                    for (auto range : desc.ranges)
+                    {
+                        while (!split && range.begin + marks_in_range < range.end)
+                        {
+                            result.emplace_back(range.begin, range.begin + marks_in_range);
+                            range.begin += marks_in_range;
+                            marks_in_range *= 2;
+                            if (marks_in_range > max_marks_in_range)
+                                split = true;
+                        }
+                        result.emplace_back(range.begin, range.begin + marks_in_range);
+                    }
+                    chassert(!result.empty());
+                    desc.ranges = MarkRanges{};
+                    ProfileEvents::increment(ProfileEvents::ParallelReplicasReadMarks, result.getNumberOfMarks());
+                    return result;
+                }
+                else
+                {
+                    /// for reverse order just return one range
+                    MarkRanges result;
+                    auto & range = desc.ranges.back();
+                    if (range.begin + marks_in_range < range.end)
+                    {
+                        result.emplace_front(range.end - marks_in_range, range.end);
+                        range.end -= marks_in_range;
+                        marks_in_range = std::min(marks_in_range * 2, max_marks_in_range);
+                    }
+                    else
+                    {
+                        result.emplace_front(range.begin, range.end);
+                        desc.ranges.pop_back();
+                    }
+
+                    /// TODO: should we need reset for each ranges?
+                    if (desc.ranges.empty())
+                    {
+                        marks_in_range = 1;
+                    }
+
+                    chassert(result.size() == 1);
+                    ProfileEvents::increment(ProfileEvents::ParallelReplicasReadMarks, result.getNumberOfMarks());
+                    return result;
+                }
             }
         }
         return std::nullopt;

src/Storages/MergeTree/MergeTreeReadPoolParallelReplicasInOrder.h

@@ -38,6 +38,8 @@ private:
     RangesInDataPartsDescription buffered_tasks;
 
     mutable std::mutex mutex;
+    bool split{false};
+    size_t marks_in_range{1};
 };
 
 };

tests/integration/helpers/cluster.py

@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ import os.path as p
 import platform
 import pprint
 import pwd
+import random
 import re
 import shlex
 import shutil
@@ -1650,6 +1651,8 @@ class ClickHouseCluster:
         minio_certs_dir=None,
         minio_data_dir=None,
         use_keeper=True,
+        keeper_randomize_feature_flags=True,
+        keeper_required_feature_flags=[],
         main_config_name="config.xml",
         users_config_name="users.xml",
         copy_common_configs=True,
@@ -1682,6 +1685,8 @@ class ClickHouseCluster:
         if not env_variables:
             env_variables = {}
         self.use_keeper = use_keeper
+        self.keeper_randomize_feature_flags = keeper_randomize_feature_flags
+        self.keeper_required_feature_flags = keeper_required_feature_flags
 
         # Code coverage files will be placed in database directory
         # (affect only WITH_COVERAGE=1 build)
@@ -2828,15 +2833,51 @@ class ClickHouseCluster:
 
                 if self.use_keeper:  # TODO: remove hardcoded paths from here
                     for i in range(1, 4):
+                        current_keeper_config_dir = os.path.join(
+                            f"{self.keeper_instance_dir_prefix}{i}", "config"
+                        )
                         shutil.copy(
                             os.path.join(
                                 self.keeper_config_dir, f"keeper_config{i}.xml"
                             ),
-                            os.path.join(
-                                self.keeper_instance_dir_prefix + f"{i}", "config"
-                            ),
+                            current_keeper_config_dir,
                         )
 
+                        extra_configs_dir = os.path.join(
+                            current_keeper_config_dir, f"keeper_config{i}.d"
+                        )
+                        os.mkdir(extra_configs_dir)
+                        feature_flags_config = os.path.join(
+                            extra_configs_dir, "feature_flags.yaml"
+                        )
+
+                        indentation = 4 * " "
+
+                        def get_feature_flag_value(feature_flag):
+                            if not self.keeper_randomize_feature_flags:
+                                return 1
+
+                            if feature_flag in self.keeper_required_feature_flags:
+                                return 1
+
+                            return random.randint(0, 1)
+
+                        with open(feature_flags_config, "w") as ff_config:
+                            ff_config.write("keeper_server:\n")
+                            ff_config.write(f"{indentation}feature_flags:\n")
+                            indentation *= 2
+
+                            for feature_flag in [
+                                "filtered_list",
+                                "multi_read",
+                                "check_not_exists",
+                                "create_if_not_exists",
+                                "remove_recursive",
+                            ]:
+                                ff_config.write(
+                                    f"{indentation}{feature_flag}: {get_feature_flag_value(feature_flag)}\n"
+                                )
+
                 run_and_check(self.base_zookeeper_cmd + common_opts, env=self.env)
                 self.up_called = True
 

tests/integration/test_keeper_map_retries/test.py

@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@ node = cluster.add_instance(
     main_configs=["configs/enable_keeper_map.xml"],
     user_configs=["configs/keeper_retries.xml"],
     with_zookeeper=True,
+    keeper_required_feature_flags=["multi_read"],
     stay_alive=True,
 )
 

tests/integration/test_refreshable_mv/test.py

@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ node1 = cluster.add_instance(
     main_configs=["configs/config.xml"],
     user_configs=["configs/users.xml"],
     with_zookeeper=True,
+    keeper_required_feature_flags=["multi_read", "create_if_not_exists"],
     macros={"shard": "shard1", "replica": "1"},
     stay_alive=True,
 )
@@ -28,6 +29,7 @@ node2 = cluster.add_instance(
     main_configs=["configs/config.xml"],
     user_configs=["configs/users.xml"],
     with_zookeeper=True,
+    keeper_required_feature_flags=["multi_read", "create_if_not_exists"],
     macros={"shard": "shard1", "replica": "2"},
 )
 nodes = [node1, node2]

tests/integration/test_storage_kafka/test.py

@@ -59,6 +59,9 @@ instance = cluster.add_instance(
     user_configs=["configs/users.xml"],
     with_kafka=True,
     with_zookeeper=True,  # For Replicated Table
+    keeper_required_feature_flags=[
+        "create_if_not_exists"
+    ],  # new Kafka doesn't work without this feature
     macros={
         "kafka_broker": "kafka1",
         "kafka_topic_old": KAFKA_TOPIC_OLD,

tests/integration/test_storage_s3_queue/test.py

@@ -99,6 +99,7 @@ def started_cluster():
             with_minio=True,
             with_azurite=True,
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             main_configs=[
                 "configs/zookeeper.xml",
                 "configs/s3queue_log.xml",
@@ -110,6 +111,7 @@ def started_cluster():
             user_configs=["configs/users.xml"],
             with_minio=True,
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             main_configs=[
                 "configs/s3queue_log.xml",
             ],
@@ -118,6 +120,7 @@ def started_cluster():
         cluster.add_instance(
             "old_instance",
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             image="clickhouse/clickhouse-server",
             tag="23.12",
             stay_alive=True,
@@ -127,6 +130,7 @@ def started_cluster():
         cluster.add_instance(
             "node1",
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             stay_alive=True,
             main_configs=[
                 "configs/zookeeper.xml",
@@ -137,6 +141,7 @@ def started_cluster():
         cluster.add_instance(
             "node2",
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             stay_alive=True,
             main_configs=[
                 "configs/zookeeper.xml",
@@ -149,6 +154,7 @@ def started_cluster():
             user_configs=["configs/users.xml"],
             with_minio=True,
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             main_configs=[
                 "configs/s3queue_log.xml",
                 "configs/merge_tree.xml",
@@ -158,6 +164,7 @@ def started_cluster():
         cluster.add_instance(
             "instance_24.5",
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             image="clickhouse/clickhouse-server",
             tag="24.5",
             stay_alive=True,
@@ -170,6 +177,7 @@ def started_cluster():
         cluster.add_instance(
             "node_cloud_mode",
             with_zookeeper=True,
+            keeper_required_feature_flags=["create_if_not_exists"],
             stay_alive=True,
             main_configs=[
                 "configs/zookeeper.xml",

tests/queries/0_stateless/02374_analyzer_join_using.reference

@@ -96,13 +96,15 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN INNER second JOIN INNER';
 First JOIN INNER second JOIN INNER
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
@@ -115,13 +117,15 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN INNER second JOIN LEFT';
 First JOIN INNER second JOIN LEFT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
@@ -134,17 +138,19 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN INNER second JOIN RIGHT';
 First JOIN INNER second JOIN RIGHT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 4	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -156,17 +162,19 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN INNER second JOIN FULL';
 First JOIN INNER second JOIN FULL
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 INNER JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -178,13 +186,15 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN LEFT second JOIN INNER';
 First JOIN LEFT second JOIN INNER
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
@@ -197,14 +207,16 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN LEFT second JOIN LEFT';
 First JOIN LEFT second JOIN LEFT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 2	UInt64	2	UInt64	Join_1_Value_2	String	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 Join_1_Value_2	String		String		String
@@ -219,17 +231,19 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN LEFT second JOIN RIGHT';
 First JOIN LEFT second JOIN RIGHT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 4	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -241,19 +255,21 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN LEFT second JOIN FULL';
 First JOIN LEFT second JOIN FULL
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 2	UInt64	2	UInt64	Join_1_Value_2	String	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 Join_1_Value_2	String		String		String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 LEFT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -266,13 +282,15 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN INNER';
 First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN INNER
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
@@ -285,17 +303,19 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN LEFT';
 First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN LEFT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 3	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64		String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -307,17 +327,19 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN RIGHT';
 First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN RIGHT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 4	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -329,19 +351,21 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN FULL';
 First JOIN RIGHT second JOIN FULL
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 3	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64		String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
+	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -354,14 +378,16 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN FULL second JOIN INNER';
 First JOIN FULL second JOIN INNER
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) INNER JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 SELECT '--';
@@ -374,19 +400,21 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN FULL second JOIN LEFT';
 First JOIN FULL second JOIN LEFT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 2	UInt64	2	UInt64	Join_1_Value_2	String	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 Join_1_Value_2	String		String		String
-	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) LEFT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -399,18 +427,20 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN FULL second JOIN RIGHT';
 First JOIN FULL second JOIN RIGHT
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 4	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) RIGHT JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
@@ -422,21 +452,23 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN FULL second JOIN FULL';
 First JOIN FULL second JOIN FULL
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
+0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 0	UInt64	0	UInt64	Join_1_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_2_Value_0	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
 1	UInt64	1	UInt64	Join_1_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_2_Value_1	String	1	UInt64	Join_3_Value_1	String
 2	UInt64	2	UInt64	Join_1_Value_2	String	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	3	UInt64	Join_2_Value_3	String	0	UInt64	Join_3_Value_0	String
-0	UInt64	0	UInt64		String	0	UInt64		String	4	UInt64	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
+	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
+	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
 Join_1_Value_0	String	Join_2_Value_0	String	Join_3_Value_0	String
 Join_1_Value_1	String	Join_2_Value_1	String	Join_3_Value_1	String
 Join_1_Value_2	String		String		String
-	String	Join_2_Value_3	String		String
-	String		String	Join_3_Value_4	String
 SELECT '--';
 --
 SELECT 1 FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 FULL JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) FULL JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);

tests/queries/0_stateless/02374_analyzer_join_using.sql.j2

@@ -64,12 +64,14 @@ SELECT 'First JOIN {{ first_join_type }} second JOIN {{ second_join_type }}';
 
 SELECT id AS using_id, toTypeName(using_id), t1.id AS t1_id, toTypeName(t1_id), t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value),
 t2.id AS t2_id, toTypeName(t2_id), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.id AS t3_id, toTypeName(t3_id), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 {{ first_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) {{ second_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 {{ first_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) {{ second_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 
 SELECT '--';
 
 SELECT t1.value AS t1_value, toTypeName(t1_value), t2.value AS t2_value, toTypeName(t2_value), t3.value AS t3_value, toTypeName(t3_value)
-FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 {{ first_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) {{ second_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id);
+FROM test_table_join_1 AS t1 {{ first_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_2 AS t2 USING (id) {{ second_join_type }} JOIN test_table_join_3 AS t3 USING(id)
+ORDER BY ALL;
 
 SELECT '--';