DROP TABLE IF EXISTS column_modify_test; CREATE TABLE column_modify_test (id UInt64, val String, other_col UInt64) engine=MergeTree ORDER BY id SETTINGS min_bytes_for_wide_part=0; INSERT INTO column_modify_test VALUES (1,'one',0); INSERT INTO column_modify_test VALUES (2,'two',0); -- on 21.9 that was done via mutations mechanism ALTER TABLE column_modify_test MODIFY COLUMN val Nullable(String); INSERT INTO column_modify_test VALUES (3,Null,0); -- till now everythings looks ok SELECT * FROM column_modify_test order by id, val, other_col; -- Now we do mutation. It will affect one of the parts, and will update columns.txt to the latest / correct state w/o updating the column file! alter table column_modify_test update other_col=1 where id = 1 SETTINGS mutations_sync=1; -- row 1 is damaged now the column file & columns.txt is out of sync! SELECT *, throwIf(val <> 'one') as issue FROM column_modify_test WHERE id = 1;