-- https://github.com/ClickHouse/ClickHouse/issues/64543 DROP TABLE IF EXISTS foo; DROP TABLE IF EXISTS bar; CREATE TABLE foo (id UInt64, seq UInt64) ENGINE = Memory; CREATE TABLE bar (id UInt64, seq UInt64, name String) ENGINE = ReplacingMergeTree ORDER BY id; INSERT INTO foo VALUES (1, 1); INSERT INTO bar VALUES (1, 1, 'a') (2, 2, 'b'); INSERT INTO bar VALUES (1, 2, 'b') (2, 3, 'c'); SELECT * FROM bar INNER JOIN foo USING id WHERE bar.seq > foo.seq SETTINGS final = 1; -- Same problem possible can happen with array join DROP TABLE IF EXISTS t; CREATE TABLE t (k1 UInt64, k2 UInt64, v UInt64) ENGINE = ReplacingMergeTree() ORDER BY (k1, k2); SET optimize_on_insert = 0; INSERT INTO t VALUES (1, 2, 3) (1, 2, 4) (2, 3, 4), (2, 3, 5); -- { echo ON } SELECT arrayJoin([(k1, v), (k2, v)]) AS row, row.1 as k FROM t FINAL WHERE k1 != 3 AND k = 1 ORDER BY row SETTINGS enable_vertical_final = 0; SELECT arrayJoin([(k1, v), (k2, v)]) AS row, row.1 as k FROM t FINAL WHERE k1 != 3 AND k = 1 ORDER BY row SETTINGS enable_vertical_final = 1; SELECT arrayJoin([(k1, v), (k2, v)]) AS row, row.1 as k FROM t FINAL WHERE k1 != 3 AND k = 2 ORDER BY row SETTINGS enable_vertical_final = 0; SELECT arrayJoin([(k1, v), (k2, v)]) AS row, row.1 as k FROM t FINAL WHERE k1 != 3 AND k = 2 ORDER BY row SETTINGS enable_vertical_final = 1; SELECT arrayJoin([(k1, v), (k2, v)]) AS row, row.1 as k FROM t FINAL WHERE k1 != 3 AND k = 3 ORDER BY row SETTINGS enable_vertical_final = 0; SELECT arrayJoin([(k1, v), (k2, v)]) AS row, row.1 as k FROM t FINAL WHERE k1 != 3 AND k = 3 ORDER BY row SETTINGS enable_vertical_final = 1;